10 Horror Movies Where The Villain Performance Outshined The Hero

One of the most significant features of horror movies is the role of the villains. Just as the hero must convey absolute fear and despair in a way that can profoundly resonate with the public, a villain is tasked with instilling terror. A genuinely outstanding antagonist does not merely scare when they are on the screen, but leaves a lasting impression that will haunt the viewers’ nightmares for a long time. To achieve that effect, the performance of the actor is of the utmost importance.

Among the many great villains in horror history, some performances have been so commanding that they have not simply earned widespread recognition but also overshadowed those of the protagonists. Whether through sheer menace or alarming unpredictability, such portrayals became the essence of the film’s horror factor, turning these characters into legends. The heroes might have been the ones the public was supposed to root for, but the villains ended up stealing the spotlight.

10

James McAvoy As Paddy

Speak No Evil (2024)

Close

Speak No Evil is a shockingly disturbing film where the escalating absurdity of the situation portrayed leaves the public, much like the story’s protagonists, simultaneously on edge and startled. However, despite the creeping sense of dread of Louise and Ben’s ambiguous feelings are well captured, who truly shines in the movie is James McAvoy.

Speak No Evil 2024 Film Poster

Like

Follow

Followed

Speak No Evil

R

Horror

Thriller

ScreenRant logo

8/10

17

7.9/10

Release Date

September 13, 2024

Runtime

110 Minutes

Cast

See All

  • Headshot Of James McAvoy

    James McAvoy

  • Headshot Of Mackenzie Davis

    Mackenzie Davis

Powered by

Expand
Collapse

The actor plays Paddy, a seemingly well-mannered and confident man who convinces the oblivious couple to spend a week with him and his wife in their isolated house in the English countryside. However, his intentions are far from pure. McAvoy’s gradual transformation from a charismatic, friendly figure to a disturbed, unsettling presence, eventually revealing the killer he truly is, is nothing short of phenomenal. Despite the sympathy the viewers may feel for the main characters, it is Paddy who keeps them captivated, always leaving them wondering which side of him will emerge next.

9

Kathy Bates As Annie Wilkes

Misery (1990)

Close

As one of the greatest villains among Stephen King’s horror creations, the director of Misery had no choice but to cast an actor who could embody the terror and depth of Annie Wilkes’ character. And Kathy Bates did it so brilliantly that she became one of the few actors to obtain an Academy Award for a performance in a horror film.

Like

Follow

Followed

Misery

R

Horror

Thriller

Drama

ScreenRant logo

10/10

13

8.5/10

Release Date

November 30, 1990

Runtime

107 minutes

Cast

See All

  • Cast Placeholder Image

    Richard Farnsworth

  • Headshot Of James Caan

    James Caan

Powered by

Expand
Collapse

As much as James Caan portrayed Paul Sheldon with the vulnerability and resilience needed for the role, it was Kathy Bates who made the movie the iconic cult film that it became over the years. The perfect, sickly-sweet nurse facade that Annie puts up to create a false sense of security for her favorite writer gradually unravels, revealing her deteriorating psyche. Bates is able to alternate between the almost contradictory facets of her role, crafting a villain who is disturbingly unpredictable and alarmingly fragile.

8

Jack Nicholson As Jack Torrace

The Shining (1980)

Close

Although Shelley Duvall’s portrayal of Wendy in The Shining has recently been reevaluated, and rightfully so, the award for the best performance in Kubrick’s eerie masterpiece still goes to Jack Nicholson. After all, the film owes much of its cult status to Nicholson’s deranged portrayal of the tormented writer Jack Torrance.

Candyman 1992, Ms. Collins from Last Night in Soho, and Hannibal Lecter.

Related

10 Horror Villains With Sad Backstories

Some horror villains have truly tragic backstories that make them complex characters, but they don’t justify their horrible actions.

Posts

The original interpreter of the Joker has a flair for playing characters who tread the subtle line between sanity and madness. Perhaps, as Stephen King said about the 1980 horror adaptation, it is true that Jack’s arch in the movie is less groundbreaking and feels occasionally flat, but Nicholson nevertheless managed to capture this more subtle transformation of the character.

Like

Follow

Followed

The Shining

R

Horror

Drama

ScreenRant logo

10/10

43

8.6/10

Release Date

June 13, 1980

Runtime

146 minutes

Cast

See All

  • Cast Placeholder Image

    Danny Lloyd

  • Headshot Of Shelley Duvall

    Shelley Duvall

Powered by

Expand
Collapse

Compared to Duvall, whose fear-driven performance is overt and unrestrained, his is more calculated, building tension with every single microexpression or tone shift. The bar scene, where he succumbs to his demons while talking to the fictitious Lloyd, remains one of the most legendary acting moments in cinematic history.

7

Hugh Grant As Mr. Reed

Heretic (2024)

Close

Despite being a dramatic departure from the charmingly witty and romantic roles he is known for, Hugh Grant proved to be an absolute powerhouse as a villain in a scary movie. Heretic is a religious horror that relies on its perfectly crafted tension as much as the chilling performance of England’s most beloved gentleman. Grant hides the true nature of Mr. Reed under such a calm and polite facade that only serves to make his wicked persona all the more disturbing.

01718402_poster_w780.jpg

Like

Follow

Followed

Heretic

R

Horror

Thriller

ScreenRant logo

8/10

27

7.9/10

Release Date

November 15, 2024

Runtime

111 minutes

Cast

See All

  • Headshot Of Hugh Grant iN The Premiere of 'Wonka' at the Regency Village Theater.

    Hugh Grant

    Mr. Reed

  • Headshot Of Sophie Thatcher In The Astra TV Awards

    Sophie Thatcher

    Sister Barnes

Powered by

Expand
Collapse

Although Sophie Thatcher and Chloe East are equally believable as the unfortunate missionaries who end up being the victims of Reed, Grant’s performance is what steals the show. The gradual realization of Paxton and Barnes in one of the first chilling confrontations is amplified by the actor’s ability to shift from a collected and proper demeanor to the sadistic menace he reveals himself to be.

6

Tony Todd As Candyman

Candyman (1992)

Close

There is a reason why Candyman is one of the most iconic villains in horror movies, and the performance of Tony Todd is certainly a key factor in that. The eerie antagonist of the 1992 film is the ghost of Daniel Robitaille, an African-American man from the 19th century who was viciously murdered due to his romantic relationship with a white woman.

Candyman (1992) - Poster

Like

Follow

Followed

Candyman

R

Horror

Drama

Thriller

4.5/10

Release Date

October 16, 1992

Runtime

100 Minutes

Cast

See All

  • Headshot Of Virginia Madsen

    Virginia Madsen

    Helen Lyle

  • Cast Placeholder Image

    Tony Todd

    Candyman

Powered by

Expand
Collapse

Between his tragic and profoundly sympathetic backstory and cruel and vengeful nature, Tony Todd represents a villain who is as haunting as he is heartbreaking. Although he appears 45 minutes into the movie and the protagonist role belongs to Helen, a semiotic graduate researching urban legends, Candyman is the heart and soul of the story. If Helen’s character embodies the archetype of the recklessly curious horror hero, Todd’s chilling portrayal elevates the character from a slasher villain to a complex figure shaped by social injustice and tragic love life.

5

Anthony Perkins As Norman Bates

Psycho (1960)

Close

At the end of the day, when one thinks of Psycho, the two images that come to mind are either the shower scene or Norman Bates’ deranged fourth-wall break. The 1960 Hitchcock masterpiece initially introduces us to the character of Marion Crane, tricking us into believing that she will be the protagonist, only to shift that role to her sister.

His ability to evoke a varied mixture of feelings in the public, from pity and sympathy to pure shock and terror, is a testament to his emotional range, portraying a man whose timid demeanor masks the terrifying monster within.

But in the end, the true heart of the movie is Norman Bates, thanks to the chilling and nuanced performance of Anthony Perkins. The actor completely outshines any other presence on the screen, as he manages to deceive everyone around him—and the viewer too—into seeing his character as a weird but good-natured man who is a victim of a domineering mother.

Like

Follow

Followed

Psycho

R

Horror

Mystery

Thriller

ScreenRant logo

10/10

12

9/10

Release Date

September 8, 1960

Runtime

109 minutes

Cast

See All

  • Cast Placeholder Image

    Janet Leigh

  • Cast Placeholder Image

    Martin Balsam

Powered by

Expand
Collapse

His ability to evoke a varied mixture of feelings in the public, from pity and sympathy to pure shock and terror, is a testament to his emotional range, portraying a man whose timid demeanor masks the terrifying monster within. His unhinged smile at the camera as he succumbs to his delusions overshadowed every other moment of the movie.

4

Ralph Fiennes As Chef Slowik

The Menu (2022)

Close

Anya Taylor-Joy is a wonderful actress, and her portrayal of Margot was magnetic, but it pales compared to the hypnotizing performance of Ralph Fiennes as villain Chef Slowik. The truth is that, if given a simultaneously terrifying and emotionally intense role, Fiennes could outshine anyone. His part in the horror movie The Menu seems custom-made for him.

Ellie Evil Dead, M3GAN, Chucky

Related

10 Horror Villains That Are Cheered For More Than The Protagonists

From M3GAN to Candyman to A Nightmare On Elm Street’s Freddy Krueger, some horror movie villains ended up becoming more popular than their victims.

Posts

His sophisticated allure and the tragic fury that his character is consumed by create a powerful and chilling figure on the screen. While the viewer might feel compelled to root for Margot and feel sorry for the fate of the other characters, the antagonistic chef still manages to evoke a deep feeling of empathy despite the cruelty of his actions.

The Menu Movie Poster

Like

Follow

Followed

The Menu

R

Comedy

Horror

Thriller

ScreenRant logo

7/10

19

8.8/10

Release Date

November 18, 2022

Runtime

106 minutes

Cast

See All

  • Headshot Of Ralph Fiennes

    Ralph Fiennes

  • Anya Taylor-Joy Profile Picture

    Anya Taylor-Joy

Powered by

Expand
Collapse

His manic grin and collected demeanor as he threatens to kill everyone in the room might be terrorizing. However, Fiennes still conveys the profound pain of his character through his melancholic, defeated gaze. The performance of Voldemort’s iconic actors turned Slowik into one of the most sympathetic villains in horror history, all through a heart-wrenching stare into the camera.

3

Tilda Swinton As Madame Blanc

Suspiria (2018)

Close

While Luca Guadagnino’s remake will never reach the heights of Dario Argento’s original Suspiria, it remains a worthy horror that effectively fulfills its promise to scare and unsettle the viewer. Despite not being the protagonist (the role is reserved for Dakota Johnson), Tilda Swinton still manages to give a commanding performance as both Madame Blanc and Helena Markos, using her solemn charisma to craft two villains that will send chills down the spine of the public.

01366456_poster_w780.jpg

Like

Follow

Followed

Suspiria

R

Horror

Mystery

Drama

10/10

Release Date

October 11, 2018

Runtime

152 minutes

Cast

See All

  • Headshot Of Dakota Johnson iN The Premiere of 'Daddio' during the 2024 Tribeca Film Festival

    Dakota Johnson

    Susie Bannion / Naomi Bannion

  • Headshot Of Tilda Swinton In The 20th Marrakech International Film Festival: 'Memory' Premiere

    Tilda Swinton

    Madame Blanc / Helena Markos / Dr. Klemperer

Powered by

Expand
Collapse

Tilda Swinton is particularly skilled at playing eerie, antagonistic figures, and her depiction here is no exception. Underneath the ethereal yet mysterious appearance of Madame Blanc, she transforms into a decayed yet commanding presence as Markos, embodying the grotesque power of the ancient leader of the coven. The actress perfectly espouses the ominous, dark aesthetic of the film, melding seamlessly with its oppressive atmosphere.

2

John Goodman As Howard Stambler

10 Cloverfield Lane (2016)

Close

The protagonist of 10 Cloverfield Lane is Michelle, a young woman played by Mary Elizabeth Winstead. After having a car accident, she finds herself in an underground bunker with Howard Stambler, who claims to have saved her from a catastrophic event on Earth. Although the story is presented through Michelle’s eyes, John Goodman as Howard steals the scenes.

10 Cloverfield Lane Poster

Like

Follow

Followed

10 Cloverfield Lane

PG-13

Drama

Horror

Mystery

Sci-Fi

Thriller

ScreenRant logo

8/10

9/10

Release Date

March 10, 2016

Runtime

103 Minutes

Cast

See All

  • Headshot Of John Goodman In The 62nd Monte Carlo TV Festival - Golden Nymphs Award Ceremony.

    John Goodman

  • Headshot Of Mary Elizabeth Winstead In The New York premiere of 'A Gentleman In Moscow'

    Mary Elizabeth Winstead

Powered by

Expand
Collapse

Michelle represents a more classic, albeit incredibly well-executed, portrayal of a horror movie survivor driven by fear, doubts, and resilience. In contrast, Howard’s character and performance are more complex and multifaceted. Goodman keeps the viewer on edge throughout the watch, suspended in a fine line between antagonist and rescuer. Although Howard presents himself as a protector, he always seems one step away from a violent outburst. The enigma behind his figure is the movie’s most powerful part. Without a doubt, this horror performance is a hidden gem in John Goodman’s works.

1

Gary Oldman As Dracula

Bram Stoker’s Dracula (1992)

Close

Gary Oldman is one of the greatest actors to ever grace the big screen. In any movie he participates in, regardless of the role he takes on, he is likely to outshine everyone else around him. This was certainly the case for Bram Stoker’s Dracula. His portrayal of the legendary figure of Count Dracula is mesmerizing and further elevates this gothic masterpiece, which is inspired by one of the most remarkable horror books in literature.

n39glc4gkbecbwdenes8zbodim8.jpg

Like

Follow

Followed

Bram Stoker’s Dracula

R

Horror

Romance

5.5/10

Release Date

November 13, 1992

Runtime

127 Minutes

Cast

See All

  • Headshot Of Gary Oldman In The 77th Cannes Film Festival

    Gary Oldman

    Dracula

  • Headshot Of Winona Ryder In The Annual Screen Actors Guild Awards

    Winona Ryder

    Mina Murray / Elisabeta

Powered by

Expand
Collapse

Although Keanu Reeves’ unconvincing British accent severely hindered his performance, he still managed to be charming as Jonathan Harker. Winona Ryder was deeply magnetic in the role of Mina, yet both actors seemed to fade in comparison to Oldman’s captivating presence. His transformative performance showcases not just the physicality of Dracula, but also the emotive depth that defines the horror character. The British star successfully honored the spooky yet nonetheless romantic allure of one of the most feared vampires in mythology.