Every Cynthia Erivo Movie, Ranked Worst To Best (Including Wicked)

At the end of 2024, Cynthia Erivo impressed audiences with her performance as Elphaba in Wicked, and following that outstanding film, many may be wondering what other amazing movies Erivo has been in. Although Wicked may have been some viewers’ first encounter with Erivo, she has been in the acting game for quite a long time. The British actress’ career began on stage, most notably with her role as Celie in The Color Purple on Broadway. Soon after, Erivo transitioned to movies and TV, jump-starting a solid screen career.

As of now, Erivo has appeared in a total of nine movies. Her tenth, Wicked: For Good, is set to premiere at the end of 2025. Currently though, the following nine movies are Erivo’s entire filmography, ranked from worst to best, including Wicked. Erivo’s best movies are those with strong critical and audience ratings, significant box office earnings, and compelling stories that come to life on screen. Meanwhile, Erivo’s worst movies missed the mark in one way or another, though they may still be worth checking out for those who admire Erivo.

9

Pinocchio (2022)

A Live Action Disney Adaptation

Close

The worst movie on Erivo’s resume at the moment is 2022’s Pinocchio. This live-action adaptation tells the beloved story of Pinocchio, a puppet who comes to life and learns that who he is inside is far more important than being “a real boy.” The film is directed by Robert Zemeckis, and stars Tom Hanks, Joseph Gordon-Levitt, Keegan-Michael Key, and Luke Evans. In the movie, Erivo plays The Blue Fairy, who brings Pinocchio to life and promises to grant his wish of being a real boy.

In general, Pinocchio was very poorly received. With a brutal 28% on Rotten Tomatoes, the movie earned praise for its visuals, but was ultimately deemed lifeless. Critics argued that 2022’s Pinocchio never offered any reason for its existence other than it could be made so it was. Erivo certainly does not give a poor performance, but nevertheless, the movie around her is so disappointing that it is definitely a contender for her worst movie.

8

Chaos Walking (2021)

A Sci-Fi World Where Men Can Hear Each Others’ Thoughts

Close

Yet another Erivo movie that garnered less-than-stellar reviews is Chaos Walking. Based on a novel by Patrick Ness, this movie takes place in a dystopian world where women have all but disappeared and men can hear each others’ thoughts. However, when a teenage boy discovers a young woman has crash-landed in his town, he begins to question the reality of his world and what he has always been told. Chaos Walking stars Tom Holland, Daisy Ridley, Mad Mikkelson, and Erivo, among others.

Chaos Walking presents a unique premise, but never fully brings it to life.

The failure of Chaos Walking is a bit more complicated than just a box office bomb. In general, Chaos Walking had all the makings of a great movie: a talented cast, strong source material, and a solid budget. However, the poor execution of director, Doug Liman, is what ultimately sunk this ship. Chaos Walking presents a unique premise, but never fully brings it to life. Everything remains underdeveloped, and therefore, uninteresting. Though some audiences did enjoy this movie, in the end, Chaos Walking remains at the bottom of Erivo’s filmography.

7

Needle In A Timestack (2021)

A Couple Is Torn Apart By A Vengeful Ex

Close

The next Erivo movie on the list may have mixed reviews, but its premise may be enough to get audiences invested. Needle in a Timestack is a sci-fi romance movie centered on Nick and Janine, who are deeply in love with each other. Yet, when Janine’s vengeful ex warps time and uses Nick’s ex-girlfriend to sabotage the pair, their romance quickly turns into a nightmare that is out of their control. Alongside Erivo as Janine, the film stars Leslie Odom Jr., Orlando Bloom, and Freida Pinto.

For the most part, Needle in a Timestack had poor reviews. Critics panned the movie for having a confusing and uninspired plot, while audiences were also left disappointed with the film’s clichés and unsatisfying ending. Despite this, Needle in a Timestack isn’t a complete waste of time. With a 52% audience score, the movie may be right up certain viewers’ allies, particularly those who enjoy romance and twisty plots. It also helps that the film has a wonderful cast and a completely singular premise.

6

Luther: The Fallen Sun (2023)

A Disgraced Detective Will Do Anything To Get Revenge

Close

One particularly interesting entry among Erivo’s resume is Luther: The Fallen Sun. A continuation of the British psychological thriller series, Luther, this movie hones in on Idris Elba’s John Luther, a police detective who has been betrayed and is now behind bars. Desperate to get revenge and take down his serial killer nemesis, Luther breaks out of jail and races against the clock to prove his innocence and save lives. Erivo plays Odette Raine, the head of the Serious and Serial Crime Unit.

Luther ran for five seasons beginning in 2010.

Fortunately, Luther: The Fallen Sun is where Erivo’s Rotten Tomatoes scores begin to steadily rise. This film has a strong 67% critics score and an even better 85% audience score. Elba reprises his role as Luther in the perfect way, bringing the same magic from the TV series to the big screen. Even those who aren’t familiar with Luther can enjoy Luther: The Fallen Sun, as the story does not rely on past plots. All in all, Luther: The Fallen Sun is far from Erivo’s best movie, but she offers up a captivating performance in a generally entertaining film.

5

Drift (2023)

A Refugee Finds Solace In A Tour Guide In Greece

Close

Although Erivo has starred in movies with big names and even bigger IPs, a more artsy film of hers is Drift. In this film, Erivo plays Jacqueline, a Liberian refugee who escapes her war-torn country for the calming sights of a Greek island. Trying hard to survive, Jacqueline is able to keep her trauma at bay, but she finds much more solace when she forms a close bond with an American tour guide, played by Alia Shawkat.

Cynthia Erivo stands on the edge of a cliff in Drift

Related

Drift Review: Cynthia Erivo Strengthens A Depthless, Unengaging Refugee Drama

The feature doesn’t dig any deeper than it has to, leaving us drifting along with Jacqueline without anything to latch onto to keep us afloat. 

Posts

Despite being hit-or-miss with audiences, Drift earned a Certified Fresh 74% critics score on Rotten Tomatoes. Admittedly, the movie is slow-paced and often lacks a solid plot, yet at its core, this is a touching tale about love, connection, and community. Jacqueline’s story is a tragic one, but that only makes the bright spots feel even brighter. Ultimately, Drift is not for everyone, but it will definitely hit for those who enjoy more abstract, indie movies.

4

Harriet (2019)

The True Story Of Harriet Tubman

Close

What could be one of Erivo’s most epic movies is Harriet. Released in 2019, this biographical film follows the real life story of Harriet Tubman, a Black woman who was born into slavery in the Deep South of 19th century America, before escaping and establishing the Underground Railroad, a famous yet dangerous system that allowed the escape of thousands of slaves. Erivo takes on the role of Tubman, alongside Leslie Odom Jr., Joe Alwyn, and Janelle Monáe.

Harriet is yet another movie that received somewhat split reviews. While some felt that the biopic did not stand out in any way, others were impressed with its fast pace and riveting story. Regardless, almost everyone agreed that Erivo’s performance was top-notch. As Tubman, Erivo brings dedication, spirit, and an undeniable sense of determination. Although Harriet is not an earth-shattering biopic, it is certainly worth watching because of its important story and admirable execution.

3

Bad Times At The El Royale (2018)

Guests Get Caught Up In A Violent Showdown At A Sketchy Motel

Close

An Erivo movie that deserves way more attention is Bad Times at the El Royale. This film is set at the tail end of the 1950s and centers on a motel called the El Royale, which sits on the line between California and Nevada. One evening, a number of strangers arrive at the motel, not realizing that they are going to be part of a violent confrontation between a young woman and the cult leader who kidnapped her little sister. Erivo plays an up-and-coming soul singer.

Once again, Bad Times at the El Royale may not satisfy everyone, but it is a unique movie that is definitely worth checking out. Erivo is joined by a truly spectacular cast, including Jeff Bridges, Jon Hamm, Chris Hemsworth, Dakota Johnson, Cailee Spaeny, and Lewis Pullman. The historical ambiance and setting of this movie is incredibly vivid, while the plot itself is a web that audiences must try to unravel. Plus, it is a joy to see Erivo play a singer, as it gives viewers a chance to hear her beautiful voice.

2

Widows (2018)

Four Widows Carry Out Their Husbands’ Botched Crime

Close

Interestingly, one of Erivo’s very best movies is the first one she ever appeared in. 2018’s Widows is a neo-noir thriller which begins when four would-be thieves are shot and killed by police. In the aftermath, their four widows, desperate for cash to pay back a vicious crime boss, concoct a plan to steal $5 million from the home of a prominent politician. Widows stars Viola Davis, Elizabeth Debicki, Michelle Rodriguez, and Erivo in the lead roles, alongside Liam Neeson, Colin Farrell, Brian Tyree Henry, and Daniel Kaluuya.

With wonderful direction by Steve McQueen and a tantalizing script by iconic thriller writer, Gillian Flynn, Widows reworks the heist genre into something new and exciting.

Widows boasts Erivo’s highest critical score on Rotten Tomatoes, with a Certified Fresh 91%. The movie is dark, disturbing, and unapologetic about the reality it is putting forth. With wonderful direction by Steve McQueen and a tantalizing script by iconic thriller writer, Gillian Flynn, Widows reworks the heist genre into something new and exciting. On top of that, Erivo gives a great performance, especially considering it was her very first big screen role. Overall, Widows earns every bit of praise.

1

Wicked (2024)

The Origin Story Of The Wicked Witch Of The West

Close

Erivo has appeared in a number of interesting movies over the years, but her best has to be 2024’s Wicked. This movie musical is a sort of prequel to The Wizard of Oz, wherein audiences meet Elphaba, a misunderstood green-skinned witch who is given the chance to hone her magic, all while rooming with the conceited Glinda. Despite their differences, the two women soon form an unbreakable bond before finding themselves at the center of a dark and dangerous conspiracy.

Elphaba from Wicked in front of a red and yellow background

Related

Wicked Gives Cynthia Erivo A Chance To Earn A Coveted Achievement That Only 21 People Have

Actress Cynthia Erivo could achieve a coveted achievement during the next awards season after her incredible performance in Universal’s Wicked.

Posts

Erivo is at her absolute best in Wicked. She completely embodies Elphaba’s strange yet brash nature, and showcases an incredibly beautiful bond with Ariana Grande, who plays Glinda. However, above all, Erivo’s performance in Wicked stands out because of her singing. In Wicked, Erivo is able to marry her acting chops with her Broadway-level singing to create a movie-going experience that is unlike anything else. Wicked is a unique project, but it has managed to cater to just about everyone. In this way, Wicked has to be Cynthia Erivo’s most impressive and iconic movie.

Movie

My Favorite Movies
My Watchlist

Success!

Wicked - Poster

Your Rating

close

10 stars

9 stars

8 stars

7 stars

6 stars

5 stars

4 stars

3 stars

2 stars

1 star

Rate Now

0/10

Leave a Review

Your comment has not been saved

Wicked

PG

Adventure

Fantasy

Musical

ScreenRant logo

9/10

362

8.7/10

Release Date

November 22, 2024

Runtime

160 Minutes

Director

Jon M. Chu

Writers

Gregory Maguire, Winnie Holzman, Dana Fox, L. Frank Baum

Cast

See All

  • Headshot Of Cynthia Erivo

    Cynthia Erivo

    Elphaba Thropp

  • Headshot Of Ariana Grande In The 2024 Met Gala

    Ariana Grande

    Glinda Upland

Powered by

Expand
Collapse